[color=#800000]Point of information.
Grantor=Seller
Grantee=Buyer
A deed
never has to be recorded, until the property is to be sold by a purchaser/owner ready to sell the property again, but the "owner" has the risk of someone attempting to claim ownership any time before filing the transaction. Lake County in its wisdom only records the Grantor, adding confusion to this scenario & many others. Most county's record both grantor and grantee.
So unless you actually go to the county and pull specific records on the property, the chain of events is muddied.
Transaction time line using available historical documents:1. A foreclosure sale occurred on
5/4/2012: Sheriff John Buncich. Grantor, to Wells Fargo Bank Na, Grantee.
http://gatewaysdf.ifionline.org/PrintForm.aspx?SDF_ID=45-2012-23731822. On
4/18/2013, REAL ESTATE SOLUTIONS OF INDIANA, LLC, Grantor appears to have attempted to record some transaction, but for what ever reason, it was not accepted or processed by the County. Reference County Record below or the link i borrowed:
http://nwigazette.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/644salesdisc.doc3. A transfer/sale occurred on
08/23/2012 Wells Fargo Bank NA Grantor, Grantor, to Real Estate Solutions of Indiana LLC., Grantee.
http://gatewaysdf.ifionline.org/PrintForm.aspx?SDF_ID=45-2012-23759034. A Contract for Deed was executed
05/01/2013 between Equity Trust Company Custodia FBO Joseph Wittig IRA Grantor, to Edwin Feliciano & (a name crossed out), Grantee.
http://nwigazette.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/644sibleyK.pdfCase filed in Hammond City Court: REAL ESTATE EQUITY SOULTIONS OF IN LLC
Case Number 45H04-1306-OV-52991
Date Filed:
2013-06-125. A Limited Liability Company Warranty Deed was
recorded in Lake County on
09/26/2013. This transaction was accepted and documents the
execution of the transfer,
although a transaction date is not recorded on the document. However, the document, accepted by LC, recorded the sale from Real Estates Solution of Indiana LLC, the "Grantor", to Equity Trust Company Custodian FBO Joseph Wittig IRA, "Grantee". The recording was approximately 4 months before the fire.
http://nwigazette.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/644deed.pdfIn summary, per the documents available, it appears the owner of this property, as of
05/01/2013 is Edwin Feliciano & (a name crossed out), Grantee.
http://nwigazette.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/644sibleyK.pdf.
So, it appears,
Real Estate Equity Soultions (sic) of Indiana, LLC didn't own the property as of
05/01/2013. It appears Edwin Felciano was the property owner six months before the fire.
Ms. Kantar filed her court documents on 06-12-2013. A full month
after Real Estate Equity Soultions (sic) of Indiana, LLC apparently sold the property to Edwin Feliciano.
From County Court Records, it appears Ms. Kantar never filed service to Edwin Feliciano on this matter. And as of this writing I can't find service to Equity Trust Company Custodian FBO Joseph Wittig IRA. To be summonsed to court, you have to have notice, notice appears not to have been served to Wittig.A legitimate question, was Kantar to busy with her legal practice, outside of her Hammond City Attorney obligation? Would a prudent attorney, have provided service to each of the individuals involved in this transaction, requesting their court presence, if only, to sort the matter out, under oath, before a judge?
Is this a misstep by Hammond's legal department? A situation complicated by, what Code Enforcement should have done? And then, adding to this, the short comings by Family Services, failing to discover a home with out utilities. Adding to the mix, a neighbor giving this family electricity via an extension cord, allowing them to continue to live in this uninhabitable unit. A situation, again complicated by the obvious poor choices the parents in this case had taken.
It appears these three children were victims of some exceptionally poor choices, made by adults, whom they depended upon to assure their safety, adults who should have been more diligent. Quote:
Ok Matt & Amy, I copied most of this from:
http://nwigazette.com/2014/01/22/a-tragedy-of-errors-fatal-hammond-fire/. I don't want to be accused of not giving credit where credit is due.
Now as to notice vs service
The defendant in the case is listed in court records as
Real Estate Equity Soultions (sic) of Indiana, LLC. Lake County property records show that the property located at 644 Sibley Street in Hammond is owned by
Equity Trust Company Custodian FBO Joseph Wittig IRA. (See the deed here: 644deed ) This deed was recorded on September 26, 2013.
There is no indication of proof of service on the
owner of record, Equity Trust Company. Even after the fire, there is no indication that the City ever attempted to amend or otherwise serve the owner of record.
Ownership of the property prior to April 2013 was in the name of Real Estate Solutions of Indiana, LLC. There is no record of a company named Real Estate Equity Soultions (sic) of Indiana, LLC ever owning the property. It appears that someone within the City erroneously merged the names of the two companies.
What should have been added to this story from the nwigazette.com is
A Contract for Deed was executed 05/01/2013 between Equity Trust Company Custodia FBO Joseph Wittig IRA "Grantor" to Edwin Feliciano & XXXXXXX "Grantee"
http://nwigazette.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/644sibleyK.pdf[/color]
http://gatewaysdf.ifionline.org/Search.aspxQuote:
Lake County's transaction record, as recorded in Lake County Records:
Parcel Number Parcel Address Current Total Value Data as of Assess Year Pay Year
45-02-36-429-013.000-023 644 SIBLEY ST, HAMMOND $42,200 1/6/2014 2012 2013
Sale Information for 9/26/2013
Grantor Real Estate Solutions of Indiana LLC Document No. 26298 Document Reference No.
Land-AV $10,000.00 Exempt Transaction N Relationship N
Improve-AV $42,600.00 Exempt Code Personal Prop Y
Total-AV $52,600.00 Transfer of Entire Parcel Y Amt. Pers Prop $0.00
Sale Date 9/26/2013 Real Prop Exchange N Condo Sale N
Total Sale Price $11,000.00 Significant Change N Adjoining Land N
Deed Type L Splits
Sale Information for 4/18/2013
Grantor REAL ESTATE SOLUTIONS OF INDIANA, LLC Document No. Document Reference No.
Land-AV $10,000.00 Exempt Transaction N Relationship N
Improve-AV $42,000.00 Exempt Code Personal Prop N
Total-AV $52,000.00 Transfer of Entire Parcel Y Amt. Pers Prop $0.00
Sale Date 4/18/2013 Real Prop Exchange N Condo Sale N
Total Sale Price $11,000.00 Significant Change N Adjoining Land N
Deed Type Splits
Sale Information for 8/23/2012
Grantor WELLS FARGO BANK Document No. Document Reference No.
Land-AV $10,000.00 Exempt Transaction Y Relationship N
Improve-AV $35,500.00 Exempt Code 3 Personal Prop N
Total-AV $45,500.00 Transfer of Entire Parcel Y Amt. Pers Prop $0.00
Sale Date 8/23/2012 Real Prop Exchange N Condo Sale N
Total Sale Price $16,000.00 Significant Change N Adjoining Land N
Deed Type Splits
Sale Information for 5/4/2012
Grantor JOHN BUNCICH SHERIFF OF LAKE COUNTY Document No. Document Reference No.
Land-AV $10,000.00 Exempt Transaction Y Relationship N
Improve-AV $35,500.00 Exempt Code 3 Personal Prop N
Total-AV $45,500.00 Transfer of Entire Parcel Y Amt. Pers Prop $0.00
Sale Date 5/4/2012 Real Prop Exchange N Condo Sale N
Total Sale Price $20,205.00 Significant Change N Adjoining Land N
Deed Type Splits
Sale Information for 3/3/2004
Grantor GARCIA, ARMANDO & IRENE GARCIA H & Document No. Document Reference No.
Land-AV $0.00 Exempt Transaction N Relationship N
Improve-AV $0.00 Exempt Code Personal Prop N
Total-AV $0.00 Transfer of Entire Parcel Y Amt. Pers Prop $0.00
Sale Date 3/3/2004 Real Prop Exchange N Condo Sale N
Total Sale Price $76,800.00 Significant Change N Adjoining Land N
Deed Type G Splits
Sale Information for 9/20/2002
Grantor GARCIA, ARMANDO & IRENE Document No. Document Reference No.
Land-AV $0.00 Exempt Transaction N Relationship N
Improve-AV $0.00 Exempt Code Personal Prop N
Total-AV $0.00 Transfer of Entire Parcel Y Amt. Pers Prop $0.00
Sale Date 9/20/2002 Real Prop Exchange N Condo Sale N
Total Sale Price $0.00 Significant Change N Adjoining Land N
Deed Type Splits
Court Record: Criminal/Traffic Defendant
Full Name REAL ESTATE EQUITY SOULTIONS OF IN LLC
S.S.N.
D.O.B.
Charge
Action Code 96.135-HA
Description AUTHORITY TO INSPECT-HA
Citation Number 644SIBLEY
Offense Date
Jurisdiction LAKE COUNTY INDIANA
Agency Hammond City Ordinance Enforcement
Court Information
Judge Jeffrey A Harkin
Appearance Date
Location Hammond City Court – H04
Balances
Total Balance Due $2,618.00
A/R Balance Due $0.00
Case Attributes
Case Number 45H04-1306-OV-52991
Status Open
Date Filed 2013-06-12
Last Updated 2013-06-12
2014-01-03 Hearing set for Event: H04 Continued Date: 01/16/2014 Time: 9:00 am Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-12-10 Hearing set for Event: H04 Order To Appear Date: 12/19/2013 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-11-13 Hearing set for Event: H04 Status Date: 12/05/2013 Time: 9:00 am Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-10-10 Hearing set for Event: H04 Add On Date: 10/10/2013 Time: 9:00 am Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-10-07 Hearing set for Event: H04 Continued Date: 11/06/2013 Time: 4:00 pm Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-08-26 Hearing set for Event: H04 Default Judgment Date: 09/26/2013 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-08-26 Court Cost (Non Traffic Related) IF or OV Charge #1: AUTHORITY TO INSPECT-HA
2013-08-26 Infraction Judgment $ 0 to be determined by Court
2013-08-26 Hearing set for Event: H04 Default Judgment Date: 09/26/2013 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-07-29 Hearing set for Event: H04 Order To Appear Date: 08/22/2013 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-07-01 Hearing set for Event: H04 Continued Date: 07/25/2013 Time: 9:00 am Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-06-12 Hearing set for Event: H04 OV Arraignment Date: 06/20/2013 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: Harkin, Jeffrey A Location: Hammond City Court – Room 232 – Tel. 219-853-6388
2013-06-12 MANDATORY COURT APPEARANCE